JOHN'S 2008 MEDIA AWARDS
While the quality of TV has eclipsed movies, I am going to start off with the movie awards because the choice of #1 just does my heart good (and it really kind of counts as TV anyway)!
THE MOVIE AWARDS:
FAVORITE MOVIE:
1. STAR TREK
I just LOVE writing that. In fact, I am going to do it again - "My favorite movie of the year was STAR TREK!!!!!!!!!!!!" THAT sentence has been a long time coming. The cast was spot-on perfect (something I would never have believed) and it still had the ethical core of Trek. Just about nearly prefect! No media event made me happier this year. Star Trek is back. Again. Thank goodness, because we need it.
2. Where The Wild Things Are
This was the most beautifully, achingly honest film I have seen in years. There was such truth in every part of it. Family is wonderful, hard, beautiful, and painful. All that and this is a film that reminds me of all the good in the universe and gives me a degree of faith and understanding. I really can't be more clear about it yet, too emotional. If you haven't seen it go now! (This is also the best story about divorce since "E.T." and that is saying a lot.)
Other Films of Note:
The rest of the movies on my list are miles away from the first two, so much so that I almost stopped at two, but they were good and deserving, although in a whole different category.
3. UP
A lovely story. Very sweet and a real depiction of love in its various forms.
4. Every Little Step
How can you miss when talking about "A Chorus Line?" This was fascinating and made me wish I could see the revival again!
5. Julie & Julia
Fun. And Meryl Streep at her best. My favorite line: when her husband asks her what she loves to do the most & she says, "EAT!" Go Julia!
6. Living in Emergency
Doctors Without Borders. Inspirational and completely fascinating. (I had to close my eyes when they were doing actual surgery though.)
THE TV AWARDS:
BEST SHOW:
1. BATTLESTAR GALACTICA
I trust I don't need to say anything else. This was the most politically relevant show in years and was a powerful character piece as well.
2. Torchwood: Children of Earth
This one ripped my heart out. It raised ethical questions which have no easy answers. It put humanity in a bind which compromised everyone's beliefs. Jack killing Steven to save the other children was horrible and unforgivable, but what else could he have done? Was there another way out? Even so, was it worth it? Gwen sums it all up in the opening line of Day Five, "There's one thing I always meant to ask Jack, back in the old days. I wanted to know about that Doctor of his. The man who appears out of nowhere and saves the world, except sometimes he doesn't. All those times in history when there was no sign of him, I wanted to know why not. But I don't need to ask anymore, I know the answer now, sometimes the Doctor must look at this planet and turn away in shame." Probably true, but at the same time, Gwen, Ianto, Rhys, and even Jack tried their best, it just wasn't enough. The show was hopeful and crushing all at the same time.
3. Doctor Who
This would have been #2 for sure, but there were only three episodes in 2009, and the much anticipated "The End of Time" only saw part 1 (part 2 airs today), so it is hard to give a final analysis (although so far, would have been a contender for #1). Even with just three hours, our beloved 10th Doctor is just wonderful and the show is consistently positive (much in the same way as Star Trek) and gives hope for the future.
4. The Sarah Jane Adventures
Elisabeth Sladen is luminous and lights us the screen. Like the Doctor, she gives us faith in humanity.
FAVORITE EPISODE:
1. Battlestar Galactica
I really saw the 2009 episodes as one story so it is next to impossible for me to break it up. I almost singled out the aftermath of finding Earth, the truth about Ellen and the Final Five, the finale, but really they stand as a unit.
2. The End of Time, part 1, "Doctor Who"
WOW! A fitting send off for David Tennant (I'm sure there will be tears a'plenty later today as we witness the regeneration later tonight).
3. The Wedding of Sarah Jane Smith, part 2, "The Sarah Jane Adventures"
David Tennant & Lis Sladen! So cool!
FAVORITE MOMENT:
1. Adama telling Kara, "I know who you are, you're my daughter…", Battlestar Galactica
At that moment, I realized it didn't matter how or why Kara came back, what mattered was who, not what, she was.
FAVORITE CLIFFHANGER:
1. The bomb *in Jack's body* explodes, destroying the Hub and leaving the fate of our Heroes in doubt, "Torchwood: Children of Earth"
Just plain exciting!
2. The Master transforms the human race, Donna starts to remember the past, and the Time Lords Return, "Doctor Who, The End of Time"
HUH? The Time Lords are calling for *the end of time itself*??? WHAT? I mean they always had some control freak tendencies, but ending TIME? That can't be good. And what did Timothy Dalton (head Time Lord) mean when he said that "even then, The Master had no concept of his greater role in events" or when he referred to The Doctor as The Master's "savior." And how did they come back? Did it have to do with Dalek Caan unlocking the Time War in order to resurrect Davros? Clearly there is more at work here than we know, and the ramifications may well extend into Matt Smith's run as the 11th Doctor.
Also, what will happen to Donna? Her final fate has been on my mind all year, I love the character and her goodbye last time around was a really sad place to leave her in. My guess is that somehow the Ood can heal her so that her mind will not "burn up" when (if?) she actually remembers her time on the TARDIS. And how is Wilf connected to The Doctor. What role does he have to play and what will he have to sacrifice to save the day? (Can the two Nobles somehow end up happy? Possibly on the Ood homeworld?)
Not to mention that all humans are now The Master, which kind of got overshadowed, but is a pretty big deal. Knowing that the regeneration is coming which lends a whole different urgency to all of these events (I can't wait for our first glimpse of Matt Smith's Doctor which I assume will be the end of the episode).
FAVORITE RETURN:
1. Donna Noble & Wilfred Mott, "Doctor Who"
I love them both and they deserve a happen ending (fingers crossed).
2. The Master, "Doctor Who"
Among other things, John Simm gives one of the performances of the year.
HOME VIDEO AWARDS:
1. Blu Ray really does look great
Star Trek (2009) looked better than it did in the theater, the Original Series looked more fantastic than I have ever seen, and the (original) Prisoner was a revelation. Not to mention things like Fringe, Bones, & other current shows. Blu Ray really does make a real, noticeable difference, much more than I originally thought. Cool.
GENERAL AWARDS:
CHARACTER OF THE YEAR:
1. Everyone, "Battlestar Galactica"
Loved them all. Every one.
2. Max, "Where The Wild Things Are"
What can I say? Wow. He's all of us really.
3. Gwen Cooper, "Torchwood: Children of Earth"
She rocks, and became TORCHWOOD's ethical center.
FAVORITE ROMANTIC COUPLE:
1. Spock and Uhura, "Star Trek"
WHAT!?!? If I had heard about this before I saw the movie, I would have been hospitalized. But it worked. It more than worked, it was a lovely relationship.
2. Laura Roslin & Bill Adama, "Battlestar Galactica"
No explanation necessary. This was a beautiful relationship from start to finish.
BIGGEST TEARS:
1. Dualla's suicide, "Battlestar Galactica"
Didn't see it coming, took me totally by surprise, but it made sense for the character. As I thought about it, I could understand it and even honor the decision.
2. Saying goodbye, "Battlestar Galactica"
Laura's death, Helo's survival, Kara's acceptance of her role in events - tears flowed all through "Daybreak."
3. The Doctor telling Wilf that regeneration feels like dying, "Doctor Who"
"If I'm killed before regeneration, then I'm dead. Even then, even if I change, it feels like dying. Everything I am dies. Some new man goes sauntering away, and I'm dead." So Russell Davies gave voice to how bummed the collective geekdom is about David Tennant's departure (and yes, we love Matt Smith already, but the 10th Doctor will always be a favorite). Plus in character, seeing the Doctor break down was very moving.
MOST HORRIFYING MOMENT:
1. The government sends troops to collect children to be sacrificed, "Torchwood: Children of Earth"
The most horrific part? I can see it actually happening. I guess in some ways it already does.
Best Convention Guest:
1. Jacob Kogan, Young Spock from "Star Trek"
This kid has more stage presence than almost anyone, if I could command that, I'd be the uber-teacher of all time!
AS WE MOVE INTO THE NEW YEAR....
Most Anticipated of 2010:
1. The 11th Doctor / Series 31
Truthfully, I already love Matt Smith. Yes, David Tennant has been my favorite Doctor since Tom Baker, but there is no denying how exciting a regeneration is. Steven Moffat has earned our confidence and there is every reason to trust his casting. I like the look of the pictures we've seen so far (the bow tie is great)! Plus our "soon to be beloved 11th Doctor" gets a full series this year which will end the "Who Drought!"
2. Caprica
Comes from a great pedigree & the pilot was very good - exploring thorny ethical questions in much the same way that Battlestar did.
3. The reveal of Twilight, BVS
No idea who s/he is and the Buffy finales are usually really exciting.
4. Iron Man 2
The first one rocked, the trailer is great, and Marvel has been nailing it with their movies!
5. The Return of TORCHWOOD
John Barrowman says the show is coming back. Jack was left in a very, very dark place and seeing he and Gwen rebuild Torchwood should be fascinating.
THE COMIC BOOK AWARDS:
FAVORITE COMIC:
1. BUFFY THE VAMPIRE SLAYER: Season 8
The quality has continued, Joss has kept it going, and it feels like a legitimate continuation of the show. Yay! We needed more Buffy.
2. Captain America
Bucky taking on the role of Cap has been a great arc. One which I think will be classic.
3. Blackest Night
Zombies aren't my usual favorite fare, but the build up to this was pretty brilliant and the various Lantern Corps have me totally engaged.
4. Ultimate Spider-Man
Still consistent fun, even after all these years.
